Police drop case against Watford pastor arrested after criticising Islam
17 November 2026
This week, police dropped the case against Christian street preacher Steve Maile, who was arrested in Watford after criticising Islam.
Seven months after arresting the sixty-six-year-old, Hertfordshire Police have decided to take no further action. Mr Maile, the senior pastor of Oasis City Church in Watford, had been preaching in the town centre on 18 April, sharing his thoughts on violence within Islam and questioning whether it is a religion of peace. He had also been singing hymns on the high street.
The father of four and grandfather was arrested by three officers on suspicion of assault and racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour. In footage of the arrest, which was widely shared online, one officer can be heard telling him: “In the name of Jesus, get in the car.” As he was handcuffed, Mr Maile insisted: “There is no offence being committed here. None whatsoever.”
He was right. The assault allegation, which Mr Maile strongly denied, was quickly dropped. The public order investigation has now gone the same way.
Mr Maile was held in custody for up to twelve hours, first at Watford Police Station and then at Hatfield Police Station, before being released on bail. He later required medical attention and wore splints on his wrists for three weeks, having been double-handcuffed in what he described as “excruciating pain” for around ninety minutes.
Hertfordshire Police said that the officers' conduct had been reviewed, and that no further action was necessary.
With the case now dropped, Mr Maile could bring a civil claim against the force over his arrest — and he should.
“I am relieved that the police have finally confirmed what I knew from the beginning: I had committed no crime.
“I was peacefully preaching the gospel, singing and speaking about my Christian beliefs. Criticising Islam is not a criminal offence. This ordeal has taken a terrible toll on me and my family.
“Being suddenly surrounded by police officers, handcuffed in front of my family and taken away as if I were a dangerous criminal was humiliating and deeply distressing.”
But he said that the emotional impact of his arrest and treatment had been far greater than the physical injuries. As is so often the case, the process is the punishment.
Mr Maile has rightly called for an apology, and has promised that he will not be silenced or intimidated. He said: “I will continue to preach the gospel publicly, including in Watford, and I will continue to tell people about the love and saving power of Jesus Christ.”
Mr Maile was represented by the Christian Legal Centre. Its chief executive, Andrea Williams, described the outcome as “sadly predictable”, adding: “Pastor Steve Maile has been completely vindicated, but he and his family should never have been forced to endure this ordeal.” She said: “The police are not there to shield Islam, Christianity or any other belief system from criticism.”
A pattern of police overreach
In recent years, we have seen the Public Order Act 1986 abused and manipulated, with the police habitually kowtowing to activists who wish to silence those who preach in the street or criticise Islam.
Section 5 of the Public Order Act 1986 makes it an offence to use threatening or abusive words or behaviour within the hearing or sight of a person likely to be caused harassment, alarm, or distress. Parliament removed the word “insulting” from section 5 in 2013, precisely to stop the offence from being used against speech that merely offends. The racially or religiously aggravated version, under section 31 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998, carries only a fine.
Criticising a religion, however robustly, is not threatening or abusive behaviour – it is a fundamental right in a liberal and free society. The courts have long recognised as much. In Redmond-Bate v DPP (1999), which concerned another street preacher, Sedley LJ held that freedom of speech extends beyond the inoffensive to the irritating, the contentious, the heretical, and the provocative. It is also worth remembering that Parliament abolished the offences of blasphemy and blasphemous libel in England and Wales in 2008.
The treatment of Christian street preachers in recent years should concern us all. For Mr Maile, it meant handcuffs, up to twelve hours in two police stations, injuries that took weeks to heal, and seven months under investigation — all for expressing views that the law plainly protects.
No one should be arrested for questioning whether Islam, or any other religion, is a religion of peace. Hertfordshire Police owe Mr Maile an apology, and forces across the country must learn from this case.
Read more in the Daily Mail.
Could you be arrested for what you say in public?
The FSU campaigns against the misuse of public order laws to criminalise lawful speech. Join 50,000+ members. From £29.99/year.
Join the FSU Today