The public are losing faith in the BBC. Why is the Government trying to force it onto our social media feeds?
20 November 2026
Ofcom’s annual report on the BBC, published yesterday, makes for scathing reading.
The British public have delivered their verdict: they increasingly believe that the BBC is less accurate, less impartial, and less trustworthy. And yet, at the very moment the national broadcaster is losing the public’s confidence, the Government is considering forcing social media platforms to put more of its content in front of them.
The figures are stark, and will make for grim reading for the top brass at the BBC. Between 2021/22 and 2025/26, the proportion of adults who said that the BBC was effective at providing accurate news and current affairs fell from 63% to 56%. Over the same period, the proportion who said that it was trustworthy fell from 63% to 55%. Most damning of all, the proportion who regarded it as impartial fell from 51% to just 45%. Fewer than half of British adults now believe that the BBC’s news coverage is impartial.
The picture is little better among people who actually use BBC News. Only 54% of them rated it highly for impartiality, well below the 65% who rated it highly for accuracy and the 63% who did so for trustworthiness. Ofcom itself acknowledged that perceptions of the BBC’s impartiality were “less favourable”.
It is not hard to see why. Last November, the BBC’s Director-General and the chief executive of BBC News resigned after a Panorama documentary was found to have spliced together separate parts of a speech by President Donald Trump, giving viewers a misleading impression of what he had said. Accusations of bias over the BBC’s coverage of Gaza, of gender, and of Brexit have dogged the corporation for years. Each controversy has chipped away at the public’s confidence that the BBC is the neutral arbiter it claims to be.
The regulator was careful to note that declining confidence in news is not unique to the BBC, and that is fair. Trust in the media as a whole has been falling for years.
But the BBC is not just another broadcaster. It is funded by a compulsory licence fee, the non-payment of which is a criminal offence. It is bound by its Royal Charter to be impartial. Its privileged position rests on a simple bargain: in return for guaranteed public money, it offers the public news they can trust to be fair. When fewer than half of adults regard it as impartial, that is not a marketing problem. It goes to the heart of the BBC’s claim on the public purse.
A broadcaster that loses its audience’s trust loses its audience — and the BBC is already losing viewers. The reach of BBC television has fallen from 50% in 2022 to just 39% today.
Ofcom’s figures should concern us all. As the public lose faith in the national broadcaster, the Government is consulting on its “Watch this Space” green paper, published in June. The paper sets out options to require social media platforms and video-sharing services to make news from public service broadcasters, such as the BBC, ITV, and Channel 4, and from undefined “other trustworthy providers” prominent and easy to find.
The stated aim is to counter disinformation. But in practice, the proposal would put the state in the business of deciding which news sources deserve a privileged place in the public’s feeds, and, by extension, which do not. Independent, critical outlets that fail to make the cut, such as GB News, would risk being pushed down the very platforms where a growing share of the public now get their news.
The News Media Association, which represents the UK’s national and local newspapers, warned that the green paper’s focus on public service broadcasters “risked obscuring” the journalism produced by independent publishers. When the paper was debated in the House of Commons, one MP put the central objection plainly: if a broadcaster’s content is not always trustworthy or unbiased, who decides whether it is?
If the BBC itself is losing the public’s trust, it is hard to see why its content should be given a privileged place in their feeds.
The term “trustworthy” sounds like a neutral, technical standard. It is not. Every judgement about which outlets are trustworthy is also a judgement about which are not, and that judgement will inevitably reflect the assumptions of whoever makes it.
Today, the label might be applied by a Labour government to favour broadcasters it regards as reliable. Tomorrow, a different government with different priorities — perhaps a future Reform UK or Conservative government — could use the same machinery to favour outlets more sympathetic to its own views. A truly free press depends on the state keeping its hands to itself.
Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) protects not only the right to impart information and ideas, but also the right to receive them, “without interference by public authority”. A scheme in which the state tilts the playing field towards approved sources sits uneasily with that principle, however benign its intentions. If this Government is so committed to remaining in the ECHR, why is it proposing a scheme that sits so uneasily with it?
The green paper has also raised alarm bells with our American friends. In the summer, Jim Jordan, the Republican chairman of the influential US House Judiciary Committee and a close ally of President Trump, wrote to the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport, Lisa Nandy, warning that the proposals from her department “would serve as a major threat” to online speech and would “infringe on the rights of American companies.”
The Free Speech Union and the US Embassy in London each submitted a response to the “Watch this Space” consultation. The embassy said:
“A framework that empowers governments to influence which sources receive preferential visibility risks becoming a mechanism for viewpoint-based censorship.
If the UK compels platforms to boost government-preferred media in algorithmic feeds, the effect on a government-disfavored speaker or media source’s reach is not meaningfully different than outright removal.
Furthermore, such a mandate could establish a template authoritarian regimes could invoke to justify more control over online content.”
In a free and democratic society, the Government should not have the power to decide which news sources are “trustworthy”, or what news its citizens can access. The answer to falling trust in the BBC is not to force its content on a sceptical public. It is for the BBC to earn that trust back, by being accurate, fair, and genuinely impartial.
The public are perfectly capable of deciding for themselves whom to trust. On the evidence of Ofcom’s own report, that is exactly what they are doing. The Government should respect that verdict, not try to override it. Both the BBC and the Government need to get a grip.
Read more at Guido Fawkes.
Who should decide which news you're allowed to see?
The FSU submitted evidence against plans to force platforms to promote government-approved news. Join 50,000+ members. From £29.99/year.
Join the FSU Today