Former Labour health minister warns that the Conversion Practices Bill could drive doctors out of the profession
17 November 2026
Another day, and another Labour MP has broken ranks with the Government to voice his concerns over the draconian Conversion Practices Bill, which is currently undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny in Parliament.
Zubir Ahmed, a practising surgeon and the Labour MP for Glasgow South West since 2024, was a minister in the Department of Health and Social Care during the Starmer Government.
He is the latest in a growing line of Labour MPs and former health ministers, including Preet Kaur Gill, who have warned about the dangers of the controversial draft Bill to end conversion practices.
Dr Ahmed said that the Bill could undermine the 2024 Cass Review into gender identity services for children, and expose clinicians who follow the Review's recommendations to criminal prosecution. As a result, the former minister fears that the Bill will lead to doctors leaving the profession. Trans activists will inevitably seek to target clinicians who refuse to affirm a gender-confused child's chosen trans identity, and to do so relentlessly.
Labour promised a Bill on conversion practices in its 2024 manifesto, which committed the party to ending abusive conversion practices. Ministers would have you believe that this is just about banning abhorrent practices such as “corrective rape”, but these practices are already, rightly, illegal. What the Bill will really criminalise are the good-faith conversations that parents and clinicians have with gender-confused children, and it will impede their ability to provide the care that these children need and deserve.
The doctor and legislator said that the Bill's protections for healthcare professionals are inadequate, and that its threshold for prosecution is too low. Writing in The Times, he said:
Some experts have even suggested that if the draft bill is not amended, it could be misused by activists as a way of targeting those clinicians who take the same cautious approach that the Cass Review set out.
Under the draft Bill, parents, therapists, clinicians, teachers, and religious leaders could face up to five years behind bars simply for having good-faith conversations with gender-confused children, for providing care, or even for sharing their faith's teachings with their congregations.
The free speech Union is deeply concerned about the impact that this Bill will have on free speech, parental responsibility, and freedom of religion. When Sir Keir Starmer led Labour to victory at the last General Election, he promised that his government would tread more lightly on the lives of the British public. This Bill is arguably the most sinister departure from that promise.
Dr Ahmed said that this piece of legislation, which the Free Speech Union has described as the most sinister, illiberal, and invasive bill to come before Parliament in a generation, risks “wading into a contested clinical space” without protecting clinicians who follow the evidence-based approach recommended by Baroness Cass.
The terms in the Bill, most notably the requirement that conduct be “abusive”, are vague and broad. Dr Ahmed said that the loose drafting and the absence of a clear definition will leave doctors uncertain whether their conduct is lawful. That is incredibly dangerous for patient safety.
The government must make sure that this draft bill does not dangerously unpick the fragile progress that has been made. We must also make sure that the clinicians who we trust to treat our young people are not pushed out of the profession by an ever more hostile environment and weak safeguards. I have seen throughout my career just how hard retaining good doctors and clinicians is. We must always do our utmost to protect and retain specialists in areas of the profession that are already difficult to work in.
Gender services are, of course, an incredibly sensitive area of medicine. The Bill will make it nearly impossible for medical professionals to navigate, given the heightened risk of vexatious complaints and the possibility of prosecution. It will undo the work of Baroness Cass and the positive developments that have come out of her review. Indeed, the peer who chaired the 2024 review has herself come out against the Bill, having previously supported it.
Read more in The Times.
Alarmed by the Conversion Practices Bill?
The FSU is fighting to stop this Bill criminalising good-faith conversations between parents, clinicians and gender-confused children. Join 50,000+ members. From £29.99/year.
Join the FSU Today