Baroness Cass comes out against the Conversion Practices Bill in scathing U-turn
17 November 2026
If the Government ought to listen to anyone when it comes to the welfare of gender-confused children, it should probably start with Baroness Cass.
The peer and paediatrician authored the 2024 Cass Review into gender identity services for children, and has sat in the House of Lords as a crossbench peer since 2024.
Many opponents of the Labour Government's draft Conversion Practices Bill, including Labour MPs such as the former health ministers Dr Zubir Ahmed and Preet Kaur Gill, have said that the Bill would directly contradict many of the recommendations made in Baroness Cass's review.
This week, the peer appeared before the Joint Committee of MPs and peers scrutinising the draft Bill, and made one of the most significant interventions yet. Baroness Cass warned parliamentarians that the legislation risks "serious unintended consequences" for parents of children experiencing gender distress and for medical professionals working in the field.
In one of the most shocking admissions of the session, Baroness Cass said that she had been given only an hour to read the draft legislation before providing a supportive comment for a Government press release in June.
In a striking blow to the Government, Baroness Cass told the Committee that she regretted backing the Bill and could not support it as drafted. She said: "Having obviously spent a long time now thinking about it, I unfortunately don't think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences." When Naz Shah, the Labour MP for Bradford West, asked her directly whether she supported the Bill as drafted, Baroness Cass replied simply: "No."
The crossbench peer had previously welcomed the Government's plan, saying that the Bill provided a "clearer" definition of what constituted conversion therapy than the draft laws proposed by successive governments since that of Theresa May.
During her appearance before the Committee, Baroness Cass said that medical professionals who work with children in gender services were fearful that they could end up being "the subject of a vexatious complaint" to the regulator, the General Medical Council (GMC). Not only could clinicians face being struck off by the regulator; under this Bill, they could also face up to five years behind bars. Baroness Cass said: "the chilling effect isn't theoretical — it's real and it's here today".
"I was trying to be as helpful as I could to the then minister. I had said I wouldn't comment until I'd seen it. It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk. So I tried to give the quotes based on the principles that I've been told about but without seeing the bill as drafted, and maybe I shouldn't have done that."
The draft Bill offers healthcare professionals some protection, but not where "the person acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position".
Baroness Cass also warned that the legislation does not sufficiently define the standards expected of medical professionals in such a contested area of medicine. She told the Committee: "It's very easy for a young person who is understandably distressed after what's inevitably a painful discussion, and possibly angry and upset that they haven't, for example, got onto the medication pathway that they want to, to feel and report that that person has behaved in what they deem to be a very negative way."
She further warned of "malign actors" on social media who are looking to exploit young people and to pursue those working in the field, and who could use this legislation as a vehicle to achieve their aims.
A concern that the Free Speech Union has consistently raised since the draft Bill was published is the chilling effect it would have on the ability of parents to have conversations with their children about gender. It should not be the role of the state, government ministers, or judges to dictate what conversations can and cannot be had between a parent and child around the dinner table.
Under this particularly sinister Bill, parents could face up to five years in prison if they try to dissuade their child from embarking on dangerous medical pathways before the age of eighteen.
Baroness Cass rightly voiced her concern about parents being "caught up" in the Bill should they refuse to affirm their child's trans identity or fail to use their preferred pronouns.
"I know there's absolutely not the intent for them to be caught up in this, but that is unavoidably potentially the risk of the way in which the bill is framed. Things like not agreeing to changing pronouns for your child, restricting money if you think they're going to use it to get a breast binder or hormones, and all of those things could fall within the reach of this bill."
The importance of Baroness Cass's intervention cannot be overstated. This is a huge blow for the Government. If it really cares about the wellbeing of vulnerable children, it is now time for the Government to listen to the professionals and withdraw this dangerous Bill.
Read more in The Telegraph.
Could talking to your own child become a crime?
The FSU is fighting the Conversion Practices Bill's threat to ordinary conversations between parents and children. Join 50,000+ members. From £29.99/year.
Join the FSU Today