Thursday, May 29, 2025
MAKE A DONATION
Get in Touch
The Free Speech Union
Member Login
BECOME A MEMBER
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us
      • Company Staff
      • Founders & Board
      • Advisory Council
      • Legal Advisory Council
      • Writer’s Advisory Council
      • Scottish Advisory Council
      • Northern Ireland Advisory Council
    • The Freedoms We Defend​
      • Freedom of Speech
      • Freedom of Expression
      • Academic Freedom
      • Freedom of the Press
      • Freedom of Religion
    • Scotland
    • Northern Ireland
  • Latest News
  • FAQS
  • Resources
    • Informative Guides
      • Online Offences Related to Civil Disorder FAQs
      • FAQs About Scotland’s Hate Crime Act
      • FAQs About What to do if You’re Contacted by Police Scotland About a Speech-Related Complaint
      • Freedom of Speech Online FAQs
      • Freedom of Expression on Campus FAQs
      • How to Make a Freedom of Information Request
      • Gender Pronouns in the Workplace
      • How to Remove Non Crime Hate Incident from your Police Record
      • Navigating Social Media and the Workplace
      • What to do if You’ve Been De-Banked
      • Anti-Racism and Unconscious Bias Training
      • The Governments Consultation on Reforming the Human Rights Act
    • Briefing Documents
    • Press Releases
    • Media
    • Letters
    • Teaching Materials
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
    • Weekly News Podcast
    • Guest Interviews & Debates
  • Events
  • Campaigns
    • Labour’s War on Free Speech
    • Higher Education Act
    • Conversion Therapy Ban
    • Say No to Banter Bouncers
    • Time to Scrap Non-Crime Hate Incidents
  • Apply For a Grant
  • Shop
The Free Speech Union
Join Today

Gender Conversion Therapy Bill talked out

  • BY Frederick Attenborough
  • March 5, 2024
Gender Conversion Therapy Bill talked out

The FSU would like to thank all those members and supporters who used our template letter to contact their MP, urging them not to support a ban on conversion therapy.

Hard Left Brighton MP Lloyd Russell-Moyle has brought forward a private members’ bill to ban ‘conversion practices’, which had its second reading in the House of Commons last week. However, thanks to the sheer number of MPs who opposed it, it was ‘talked out’, meaning it’s now at the bottom of a pile of legislation to be debated, and extremely unlikely to ever see the light of day.

Given that Russell-Moyle’s bill would have created a number of unintended consequences, including effectively criminalising parents, doctors, clinicians, people of faith, and teachers who, in their conversations with others, challenge, criticise or deviate from the basic tenets of gender identity ideology, this was a significant victory for free speech.

But we’re not home and dry yet. 

Not only is there another, similar Bill wending its way through the House of Lords (which we’ve written about here), but during the second reading of Russell-Moyle’s Bill, a minister let slip that the government plans to publish its own draft legislation to ban conversion therapy once the Cass Review into NHS gender treatment of children has published its Report.

That’s disappointing news, and many, if not all, of the free speech concerns raised during the debate on Russell-Moyle’s Bill will now need to be articulated again later this year.

As Neale Hanvey (Alba) put it, “this type of legislation is the thin end of the wedge, and it has the potential to be the most dangerous, regressive, illiberal and authoritarian policy proposal that I have ever witnessed in my lifetime”.  

In another powerful intervention, Miriam Cates (Con) read out testimonies from parents whose young children had been pushed towards transitioning thanks to an ‘affirmative’ medical approach to gender dysphoria, which those parents had been denounced, castigated and ostracised for opposing.  

“My particular concerns are for parents who sadly absolutely could be criminalised under this Bill,” she said, adding that it would “very likely to lead to parents being prosecuted, or at least to feeling that they cannot speak freely to their children, as they would wish to keep them safe and prevent them from making irreversible decisions.”

Speaking for the Government, Maria Caulfield MP described how the government has “encountered challenges” in attempting to develop its own Bill: “[N]otably ensuring that legislation is clear, balanced and respects freedom of speech, belief and religion, and does not cause unintended consequences for parents, clinicians, teachers or religious groups.”

One of the problems with legislating in this area has to do with the complexity of the definitional work required. When Labour Equalities Minister Anneliese Dodds said her party was supporting the Bill, Conservative MP Caroline Ansell intervened to ask for more clarity. “She has now said the word ‘practices’ five times, and she has said: ‘Conversion practices are abuse.’ So that I can better follow her, will she describe the scale, scope and nature of the practices that she references.”

“All the examples are detailed in the Bill,” Ms Dodds responded, incorrectly, drawing the attention of the Chamber to a piece of legislation that, according to the human rights barrister Jason Coppel KC, contains such an open-ended definition of ‘conversion practices’ that it will likely bring an alarmingly wide range of perfectly lawful social and religious activities within scope of the ban.

Sir Liam Fox (Con) and Suella Braverman (Con) also both pointed to the fact that while there are some forms of ‘conversion therapy’ no sensible person would object to being banned, such practices are already illegal in the UK.

“Good law,” Sir Liam commented, “needs to be necessary, clear, effective and enforceable and to avoid unintended consequences. Like many in the House, I am not clear exactly what the necessity is for the Bill, because I did not hear described in any clarity the sort of offences that are not covered by legislation already and that would require yet another piece of legislation.”

Former Home Secretary Suella Braverman noted that the “offensive and abhorrent practices that we are talking about but cannot yet evidence”, including corrective rape, electroshock therapy, forced marriage, holding down while praying, and so on, are “already criminal under myriad laws, ranging from the Sexual Offences Act 2003 to the Protection from Harassment Act 1997.”

Previous Post

Academics self-censoring out of fear of being bullied, says Vice Chancellor

Next Post

The North Face offers huge discount only if customers complete woke course

Join the Free Speech Union

One annual investment for complete peace of mind.

As a member, you’ll have access to an array of resources and support, ensuring you can speak your mind without fear of being cancelled. Our experienced team provides guidance, support and – at our discretion – assistance with legal action. We will defend your right to speak your mind, however unorthodox your views, provided you don’t say anything unlawful.

Join Today

Make a Donation

Listen to our weekly news podcast

Listen to Our Past Interviews & Debates

IN THE MEDIA

News Archive

Join Our Community

Become a Member
Make a Donation

© The Free Speech Union Limited

Quick Links

Member Login
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Cookie Policy
Legal
FAQs
Facebook Twitter-square Youtube

Organisation Address

The Free Speech Union
85 Great Portland Street

London W1W 7LT
+44 020 3920 7865

Get in Touch
Media Enquiries email

Welcome to the Free Speech Union


If you’re looking for information and guidance, or in need of immediate help, please click the button below:
GET IN TOUCH
  • Become a Member
  • Make a Donation
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us
      • Company Staff
      • Founders & Board
      • Advisory Council
      • Legal Advisory Council
      • Writer’s Advisory Council
      • Scottish Advisory Council
      • Northern Ireland Advisory Council
    • The Freedoms We Defend​
      • Freedom of Speech
      • Freedom of Expression
      • Academic Freedom
      • Freedom of the Press
      • Freedom of Religion
    • Scotland
    • Northern Ireland
  • Latest News
  • FAQs
  • Resources
    • Informative Guides
      • Online Offences Related to Civil Disorder FAQs
      • FAQs About Scotland’s Hate Crime Act
      • FAQs About What to do if You’re Contacted by Police Scotland About a Speech-Related Complaint
      • Freedom of Speech Online FAQs
      • Freedom of Expression on Campus FAQs
      • How to Make a Freedom of Information Request
      • Gender Pronouns in the Workplace
      • How to Remove Non Crime Hate Incident from your Police Record
      • Navigating Social Media and the Workplace
      • What to do if You’ve Been De-Banked
      • Anti-Racism and Unconscious Bias Training
      • The Governments Consultation on Reforming the Human Rights Act
    • Briefing Documents
    • Press Releases
    • Media
    • Letters
    • Teaching Materials
  • Videos
  • Podcast
    • Weekly News Podcast
    • Guest Interviews & Debates
  • Events
  • Campaigns
    • Labour’s War on Free Speech
    • Higher Education Act
    • Conversion Therapy Ban
    • Say No to Banter Bouncers
    • Time to Scrap Non-Crime Hate Incidents
  • Apply For a Grant
  • Member Login
  • Shop